The Early Years - Pro Football's Roots

The 1900's through the 1945

 

This is page is dedicated to those Cleveland area teams and people that paved the way for the institution we now call the NFL and the Cleveland Browns. In this page, you will find out that Ohio was the center of professional football. You will also learn about early Ohio teams, their coaches, leagues, players, and statistics. Please note that there is some information on this page that I have failed to dig up, and if you know any of this information, please let me know. My goal in this is to be 100% accurate and have 100% of the information. Thanks and enjoy!

 

*************************************************************************************

Past Cleveland Teams:

This is a list of all of the professional Cleveland teams of the past. A couple of notes about this section: There are 3 instances of "Cleveland Indians" in this list. That is because the first two went out of business. They were three separate teams, with different players and different owners. If there is a (c) in the playoff column, it denotes a championship game. A double question mark (??) denotes missing information. If you can supply the information, I would be more than happy to list you as a source on my credit page, as well as provide a link to any page you may have. Click on the link in the highlight column to view a short story about the team. And finally, once again, if there is any information that you feel is incorrect on this page, please let me know. I hope that you will find this reading as interesting as it was for me to research and write.

Name
Year
League
Record
Finish
Playoff* Coach highlight
Tigers
1920
APFA
1-4-2
9th
None Stan Cofal  
 
1921
AFPA
3-5-0
11th
None Jim Thorpe  
Indians
1923
NFL
3-1-3
5th
None Cap Edwards  
Bulldogs*
1924
NFL
7-1-1
1st
Note1 Guy Chamberlin  
 
1925
NFL
5-8-1
12th
None Cap Edwards  
Panthers
1926
AFL
3-2-1
3rd
None Ray Watts Note 2
Bulldogs
1927
NFL
8-4-1
4th
None Roy Andrews  
Indians 1931 NFL 2-8-0 8th None Al Cornsweet/ Hodge Workman  
Rams
1937
NFL
1-10-0
5W**
None Hugo Bezdet  
 
1938
NFL
4-7-0
4W**
None Hugo Bezdet/ Art Lewis  
 
1939
NFL
5-5-1
4W**
None Dutch Clark  
 
1940
NFL
4-6-1
4W**
None Dutch Clark  
 
1941
NFL
2-9-0
5W**
None Dutch Clark  
 
1942
NFL
5-6-0
3W**
None Dutch Clark  
 
1943
NFL
Note3
-
- -  
 
1944
NFL
4-6-0
4W**
None Buff Donelli  
Rams
1945
NFL
9-1-0
1W**
Beat Was 15-14 c Adam Walsh
NY Times Article

* - Formerly the Canton Bulldogs (1920-1923)

** - W means NFL Western Division

Note1: The Bulldogs played a post-season game with the Chicago Bears, and the Bears won 11-5. The local Chicago newspapers declared Chicago the champions, however, in the off-season before, George Halas (owner and coach of the Bears) pushed through a rule that awarded the league championship to the team with the best winning percentage in the regular season. Cleveland had the best record and was awarded the championship despite protests from Chicago.

Note 2: Went out of business and disbanded after 6 games.

Note 3: Did not play that year Due to WWII. Some players were "leased" out to other teams for that year, but were still under contract with Cleveland.

************************************************************************************

Other Ohio Teams

The same applies to this table of information as did above. The reason that I have included the following team information on this page is because Northeast Ohio was the center of the pro football world in the early days. The area is rich in tradition, and there are many stories to tell, and I would like to tell them all.

Name
Year
League
Record
Finish
Playoff* Coach Hilite
Akron Pros
1920
AFPA
6-0-3
1st
Note A Elgie Tobin  
1921
AFPA
8-3-1
3rd
None Tobin/Fritz Pollard  
1922
NFL
3-5-2
10th
None Paul Sheeks  
1923
NFL
1-6-0
17th
None Dutch Hendrian/ Carl Cramer  
1924
NFL
2-6-0
13th (t)
None Jim Fowler  
1925
NFL
4-2-2
5th
None George Berry/ Fritz Pollard  
     
Akron Indians
1926
NFL
1-4-3
16th
None Fritz Pollard/ Al Nesser  
Canton Bulldogs
1920
AFPA
4-3-1
7th
Note B Jim Thorpe  
1921
AFPA
5-2-3
4th
None Cap Edwards/Bob Higgens  
1922
NFL
10-0-2
1st
None Guy Chamberlin  
1923
NFL
11-0-1
1st
None Guy Chamberlin  
Canton Bulldogs
1925
NFL
4-4-0
11th
None Harry Robb  
 
1926
NFL
1-9-3
20th
None Harry Robb/ Pete Henry  
Marion Oragne Indians
1922
NFL
3-6-0
12th
None Jim Thorpe  
1923
NFL
1-10-0
18th
None Jim Thorpe  
Dayton Triangles
1922
NFL
4-3-1
7th
None Carl Storck  
1923
NFL
1-6-1
16th
None Carl Storck  
 
1924
NFL
2-6-0
13th (t)
None Carl Storck  
 
1925
NFL
0-7-1
19th
None Carl Storck  
 
1926
NFL
1-4-1
17th
None Carl Storck  
 
1927
NFL
1-6-1
10th
None Lou Mahrt  
 
1928
NFL
0-7-0
9th
None Fay Abbott  
 
1929
NFL
0-6-0
12th
None Fay Abbott  
Columbus Bullies
1921
AFL
??
??
?? ??  
Columbus Panhandles
1920
AFPA
0-5-0
14th
None Ted Nesser  
1921
AFPA
1-8-0
17th
None Ted Nesser  
1922
NFL
0-8-0
18th
None Herb Dell  
Columbus Tigers
1923
NFL
5-4-1
8th
None Pete Stinchcomb/Gus Tebell  
1924
NFL
4-4-0
10th
None Red Weaver  
1925
NFL
0-9-0
20th
None Red Weaver  
1926
NFL
1-6-0
19th
None Jack Heldt  
Cincinatti Bengals
1927
NFL
??
??
?? ?? Got info?
Cincinatti Bengals
1931
NFL
??
??
?? ?? Got info?
Cincinatti Celts
1921
AFPA
1-3-1
14th(t)
None Bill Doherty  
Cincinatti Reds
1933
NFL
3-6-1
None Al Jolly/ Mike Palm  
 
1934
NFL
0-8-0
5th
None Algy Clark  
Portsmouth Spartans
1930
NFL
5-6-3
8th
None ??  
 
1931
NFL
11-3-0
2nd
None ??  
Toledo Maroons
1922
NFL
5-2-2
4th
None Guil Falcon  
1923
NFL
3-3-2
11th
None Guil Falcon  
Note A: Akron was considered the "Ohio Champions" because they did not play any teams from another state. The Chicago Staleys had a record of 8-0-0, and played three post-season games. Chicago newspapers declared the Staleys Champs because of the post-season games and their record in the "regular season", and they declared the Pro's "Ohio Champs".

Note B.: The Bulldogs played in an unsanctioned post-season game with the Chicago Staleys and lost.

**********************************************************************************

This page has been visited 1144 times since 6/22/01
Cleveland Browns History is an independent football site dedicated to giving all fans free access to a complete library of Cleveland Browns information. This site is not affiliated with the Cleveland Browns, the National Football League, or any of their affiliates. This site does not generate profit, nor does it have expenditures. All photographs are property of their respective owners and may not be reproduced.
All code, content, and format is copyright 2000-2001 FDM Netertainment Services, Frank D. Mann, and/or the Cleveland Browns History Site unless otherwise specified. All rights reserved. All articles and editorials may be reproduced provided appropriate credit is given to this site.